In an October 23, 2026 order in Tortell v. Breakers FC Academy Inc., et al. (Santa Clara Super. Ct., Case No. 25CV474114), the trial court rejected the defendants’ argument that officers and directors of non-profit organizations in California are exempt, as a matter of law, from personal liability under California Labor Code section 558.1. Terp Law P.C. represents the plaintiff.
Section 558.1
Section 558.1 gives employees a private right of action to hold certain individuals personally liable for wage and hour violations. The statute provides:
558.1. (a) Any employer or other person acting on behalf of an employer, who violates, or causes to be violated, any provision regulating minimum wages or hours and days of work in any order of the Industrial Welfare Commission, or violates, or causes to be violated, Sections 203, 226, 226.7, 1193.6, 1194, or 2802, may be held liable as the employer for such violation.
(b) For purposes of this section, the term “other person acting on behalf of an employer” is limited to a natural person who is an owner, director, officer, or managing agent of the employer, and the term “managing agent” has the same meaning as in subdivision (b) of Section 3294 of the Civil Code.
(c) Nothing in this section shall be construed to limit the definition of employer under existing law.
The Allegations
In Tortell, plaintiff alleges that an elite soccer club ceased paying its coaching staff mid-way through the 2024-2025 soccer season, but then suffered and permitted the coaches to continue to without pay. The lawsuit seeks to hold two of the club’s officers personally liable under Section 558.1 for their role in the Labor Code violations.
The Court’s Ruling
On a demurrer, the individual defendants argued that they could not be liable under Section 558.1 because the statute was not meant to cover officers and directors at non-profit organizations. The court disagreed:
The text of Labor Code section 558.1 weighs against the proposed carve-out. Section 558.1(b) defines the covered class as a natural person who is an owner, director, officer, or managing agent of the employer, without distinguishing between for-profit and nonprofit employers. (Labor Code § 558.1(b).) The Legislature expressly identified the persons covered and did not limit coverage by corporate form.
Corporations Code section 5231 does not compel a different result at the pleading stage. The better reading is that Corporations Code section 5231 governs a nonprofit director's standard of care and exposure for an alleged failure to discharge obligations as a director to the corporation, while Labor Code section 558.1 creates an independent liability mechanism directed at wage-theft violations by enumerated natural persons acting on behalf of the employer. These are not the same subject. To the extent there is tension, Labor Code section 558.1 is the more specific statute on wage-and-hour liability and the later-enacted statute targeted to exactly this subject.
Authority also shows that Labor Code section 558.1 has been treated as applicable to natural persons serving as officers or directors at a nonprofit entity, where they were found personally liable because they were in charge and made operational decisions, and the opinion did not identify a nonprofit exception. (See, Lorenzo v. San Francisco Zen Ctr. (2025) 116 Cal.App.5th 258, 281-282; [] (Usher v. White (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 883, 894)
Here, the SAC alleges: (i) Lepa was a board member, Chief Executive Officer, and the agent for service of process for Breakers; (2) Rob was a board member and Chief Financial Officer of Breakers; (3) in late February 2025, Plaintiff spoke up on behalf of himself and other coaches, in a Zoom meeting with Lepa; (4) in March 2025, Lepa responded to plaintiff’s wage complaints by criticizing his relatively high salary; (5) on March 31, 2025 Plaintiff emailed Lepa and Rob requesting payment by April 1, 2025, and informed them of possible legal actions. Lepa responded in WhatsApp informing Plaintiff that Breaker was defunct. (SAC ¶¶ 6, 7, 23-30)
Reading these allegations liberally, as the Court must, they support the inference that Lepa personally acted on behalf of the employer in causing or directing the challenged wage practices.
(Oct. 23, 2026 Order at pp. 8-9 [referring to the individual defendants by their first names].) The court overruled the CEO’s demurrer and sustained the CFO's demurrer with leave to amend.
Why it Matters
Trial court rulings are not binding precedent and are generally not citeable as authority. But they can offer useful reasoning. This decision squarely addresses an argument non-profit employers may try to raise: that their corporate form shields their individual officers and directors from Section 558.1. The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute draws no such distinction.
This reasoning is important because Lorenzo and cases like it involve appeals from the Labor Commissioner proceedings where defendant is a religious organization and a carveout for non-religious nonprofits is not specifically discussed. (See Lorenzo, 116 Cal.App.5th 258, review granted S294565; Ehrenkranz v. San Francisco Zen Ctr. (2026) 118 Cal.App.5th 977, review granted, S296143.) Lorenzo and Ehrenkranz do support the principal of Section 558.1’s broad applicability.
This ruling was made at the pleading stage and does not decide the merits of the case. Results in any case depend on its own facts and do not guarantee a similar outcome in another matter.